Get your phone out. I’ve audited around 150 podcasts, and this time we’re auditing yours, together, while you listen.

It’s episode 100, so instead of a party I’m doing the thing people usually pay me for: the four checks I run on every show before I write a word of an audit. You pause me, check your own show, come back, and we score it.

Check one is how quickly your latest episode gets going, and how clean the edit is getting there. Check two is how your voice is recorded. Check three is your last three titles, and I fail that one on air. Check four is the bit of your description people see before it says “more”.

Checks three and four, a machine can do, so I built one. Paste your RSS feed or your show name into the free health check and you’ll get a score out of 10 in red, amber and green, the same standard I use in my paid audits. If you want me actually listening to your show, the Lite audit is at the end of your results.

Chapters

03:27">03:27 Check one: editing

04:56">04:56 Check two: your voice

06:16">06:16 Check three: titles

08:27">08:27 Check four: descriptions

09:11">09:11 The score

09:53">09:53 The free tool

11:35">11:35 Your one thing

12:31">12:31 Close

Links

Free podcast health check: podmastery.co/health-check

When it’s bigger than four checks: https://podmastery.co/need-podcasting-help/

Free 7-day podcast makeover email course: podmastery.co

Listener survey (free download as a thank-you): podmastery.co/listener-survey

Transcript
Speaker:

This is episode 100 of Podmastery Podcasting Insights, and before we

Speaker:

start, I need you to do something.

Speaker:

Get your phone out, open your favorite podcast app, and find your own show.

Speaker:

Yours, not this one, yours.

Speaker:

If you're driving, then obviously don't.

Speaker:

Keep listening and come back to this bit when you're parked up.

Speaker:

I'd quite like you around with us to hit episode 101.

Speaker:

If you're not driving, go on, grab your phone, find your show.

Speaker:

I'll wait.

Speaker:

All right.

Speaker:

Got it?

Speaker:

Good.

Speaker:

Because this is episode 100, we're gonna do something a little bit different.

Speaker:

We're not gonna throw a self-congratulatory party where I'm

Speaker:

gonna replay clips of my favorite episodes or the most popular episodes

Speaker:

or any of that nonsense that shows celebrating milestones tend to do.

Speaker:

No, because this show is all about you.

Speaker:

It's not about me.

Speaker:

So we're gonna do something for you.

Speaker:

We're gonna audit your podcast together in real time right now

Speaker:

Hello, I'm Neal Veglio, the podmaster, and this is Podmastery Podcasting Insights.

Speaker:

I've been doing the podcasting thing for more than 25 years, in audio for 30.

Speaker:

and a quick confession from me before we get going with this.

Speaker:

A while back, on this very same podcast, I said that a podcast that genuinely fixed

Speaker:

your problems would probably be about 10 episodes long, and this is episode 100.

Speaker:

So make of that what you will.

Speaker:

Of course, there is nuance to everything, as I always say.

Speaker:

And when I said that, I was kind of thinking more in general terms of

Speaker:

going to the extreme of understanding when a show is self-interested.

Speaker:

In other words, when it's gatekeeping the real insight behind a paywall or behind

Speaker:

a book or behind its own vanity metrics of building followers and downloads and

Speaker:

all that stuff, then yeah, in theory, if a show is actually genuinely helping

Speaker:

you, it should probably have done its job within a handful of episodes.

Speaker:

But what that doesn't really fully explain is that when you've got something

Speaker:

as complicated as an industry such as podcasting, such as marketing in

Speaker:

general, you can't really get everything knocked off in 10 episodes, can you?

Speaker:

So like with everything, I said something in the most extreme version of what it

Speaker:

actually inhabits just to get you thinking

Speaker:

So here's what we're gonna get for episode 100 instead of a slice of cake.

Speaker:

Over the years, I've audited around 150 podcasts.

Speaker:

People usually pay me to do that for them, and the first thing I do every single

Speaker:

time is listen to the most recent episodes and check for a few of the same things.

Speaker:

Now, you're about to do these for yourself on your own show

Speaker:

while I talk you through it

Speaker:

Our first check is the editing.

Speaker:

So go to your latest episode, and in a moment when I tell you to, pause

Speaker:

this and press play and listen to the first minute, then come back.

Speaker:

All right?

Speaker:

So I'm not going anywhere.

Speaker:

Pause me now

Speaker:

Welcome back.

Speaker:

So two questions.

Speaker:

First of all, did you get into it quickly enough?

Speaker:

Did you get to the reason that your listener would have pressed play?

Speaker:

Was there a warm-up, a hello and welcome, a bit about the weather, a bit about

Speaker:

the weather where your guest is, a bit about where you're both apologizing for

Speaker:

the sound of the builders next door?

Speaker:

And then, and this is my favorite, the builders don't actually make a sound

Speaker:

for the whole episode, so the only thing anyone remembers is the apology

Speaker:

for the thing that never happened.

Speaker:

Secondly, how good was the edit getting them there?

Speaker:

Was it clean?

Speaker:

Or would I, as a listener, hear the joins?

Speaker:

Maybe a breath that stops halfway, an um that only half got cut, maybe another

Speaker:

um immediately after it which you missed

Speaker:

And here's a bigger question which you're gonna cringe over.

Speaker:

If you were tempted to skip forward in your own episode, even just a

Speaker:

little bit, so is everybody else.

Speaker:

They just didn't come back and tell you.

Speaker:

So make a note of that.

Speaker:

And we're gonna make check two now, which is your voice.

Speaker:

Okay, so we're gonna do it again, same thing, same minute And play

Speaker:

it again and then come back to me.

Speaker:

And this time, ignore what you're saying.

Speaker:

Just listen to how you're saying it, how it's recorded.

Speaker:

All right, you ready?

Speaker:

Get ready to pause me and press play.

Speaker:

Go

Speaker:

All right, hopefully you came back.

Speaker:

So does this sound close?

Speaker:

Does this sound clear?

Speaker:

Does this sound like we're sat next to you on the train?

Speaker:

Maybe in a theater waiting for a performance,

Speaker:

but with clear audio using something like maybe WhatsApp or FaceTime.

Speaker:

Or does it sound roomy and echoey, boxy, a bit of a ring to it like you

Speaker:

recorded it in a bathroom or a small carpeted cathedral full of coats?

Speaker:

Because that's the first thing that a new listener will be judging you on before

Speaker:

they've even heard a single idea from you.

Speaker:

You could have the best idea in your whole niche, but if it arrives sounding

Speaker:

like it was phoned in from inside a wardrobe, it doesn't get the chance

Speaker:

to be the best idea in your niche

Speaker:

All right, I think the pausing bit is done now because I'm

Speaker:

gonna hurt my own retention here.

Speaker:

So let's go with the things that don't require listening.

Speaker:

Let's go through the metadata.

Speaker:

So starting off, check three, titles.

Speaker:

Look at your most recent three episode titles.

Speaker:

Just read them to yourself

Speaker:

Would a stranger tap on any of them?

Speaker:

Somebody who's never heard of you.

Speaker:

On the bus, their thumb itching to click on something.

Speaker:

Is there a guest's name in there?

Speaker:

Because I'm gonna tell you, unless your guest is genuinely famous, and I

Speaker:

mean famous like a household name, like your mum's heard of them level famous.

Speaker:

Unless that's the case, nobody's tapping on a name.

Speaker:

A name doesn't tell me what I'm gonna be getting out of listening.

Speaker:

And now read all that together, all three, out loud if you're on your own.

Speaker:

Do they sound like they come from the same show?

Speaker:

I did this on mine before I sat down to record this very episode,

Speaker:

and here are my most recent three.

Speaker:

And let's be a little bit fair to this because the most recent before

Speaker:

this one was a bonus episode.

Speaker:

It was in the Opinions brand.

Speaker:

But the titles were Opinion: They're Telling Us There Are Too Many Ads,

Speaker:

How To Read A Podcast Script Without Sounding Like You're Reading,

Speaker:

and Here's What Definitely Won't Make Your Podcast Sound Better.

Speaker:

One's about ads, one's about reading a script, one's about what won't make you

Speaker:

sound better, and all three are true.

Speaker:

All three are useful, and read together, they sound like three different shows

Speaker:

that happen to share a microphone.

Speaker:

100 episodes in, my weak spot is the theming.

Speaker:

Yeah, I'm not gonna fix that in this episode, but I wanted you to hear

Speaker:

me say that out loud because if the bloke who audits podcasts for a living

Speaker:

can fail check three on his 100th episode, you're allowed to fail, too.

Speaker:

You're just not allowed to ignore that failure.

Speaker:

All right, now on to check four, which is descriptions.

Speaker:

Open your latest episode and read only the bit that you can see before it says more.

Speaker:

That's it.

Speaker:

That's all most people ever read.

Speaker:

Does that first line give a stranger a reason to click play on the player,

Speaker:

or does it say, "In this episode…"?

Speaker:

Because they know it's an episode.

Speaker:

They're inside a podcast app.

Speaker:

You've spent the most valuable line that you've got there

Speaker:

telling them where they are.

Speaker:

It's a bit like titling your podcast The X Podcast

Speaker:

It's the episodic equivalent of that.

Speaker:

It's a shop window with a sign in it that says shop

Speaker:

So let's get to the score then.

Speaker:

And this is by far not the end of this.

Speaker:

Don't worry, there is a very practical thing that we can get you to do if any

Speaker:

of this feels a little bit overwhelming.

Speaker:

But how many of those things did you pass?

Speaker:

If it's all four, brilliant.

Speaker:

Although I'd probably suggest getting someone else to check because nobody

Speaker:

marks their own homework harshly.

Speaker:

If you failed on the first one, the getting into it and the edit,

Speaker:

I'm gonna be straight with you.

Speaker:

Your listeners discovered that before you did.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And that's not a lovely thing to hear on a Monday, but every one of these

Speaker:

things is fixable this week, and not one of them is gonna cost you a penny

Speaker:

And now onto checks three and four, the titles and the descriptions.

Speaker:

And that's something that a tool can do, especially one I've built it.

Speaker:

So what I'd like you to do, because we're gonna keep coming back to this, I want

Speaker:

you to be able to practically sit down and continue auditing the basics of your show.

Speaker:

Go to podmastery.co/health-check

Speaker:

And then paste in your RSS feed.

Speaker:

Or if you don't have your RSS feed, just put your show name in there.

Speaker:

What this tool of mine does is it looks at your latest episodes, and it gives you a

Speaker:

score out of 10 in red, amber, and green.

Speaker:

It's completely free, and it uses the same red, amber, green technique that

Speaker:

I use in my audits that people pay for.

Speaker:

So it's the same standard.

Speaker:

It's just quicker, and honestly, a lot less emotional.

Speaker:

What it can't do is checks one and two, whether you get into it

Speaker:

quickly enough, how clean your edits are, how your voice is recorded.

Speaker:

A tool can tell you that your title's too long.

Speaker:

It just can't listen and tell you that you sound like you're

Speaker:

podcasting from inside a wardrobe.

Speaker:

That bit needs the ears, and that's the full audit.

Speaker:

That's me actually listening to your show, and you'll find the opportunity

Speaker:

to do that within your results.

Speaker:

Just stick your show name in there or your RSS feed and

Speaker:

click the Check My Show button.

Speaker:

You'll then get a follow-up email if you want it, and that will give you

Speaker:

the option to follow up with an audit.

Speaker:

So here's your one thing that you need to do for this week.

Speaker:

Pick the check that you failed worst at, just that one, and fix that

Speaker:

before your next episode goes out.

Speaker:

If it's your titles, write the next one out three times before you publish it.

Speaker:

Choose the one that resonates the most.

Speaker:

If you feel like it, stick it into your AI tool of choice and get it to give you

Speaker:

reasons why each is good or each is bad.

Speaker:

If it's your description, write a first line that would

Speaker:

make you want to press play.

Speaker:

Or if you wanna go really deep into this, ask somebody that isn't your

Speaker:

mum to give you their opinion on what would make them press play.

Speaker:

And if it's the edit or the voice, start with that first minute.

Speaker:

Get that minute right, and then the rest of your episode gets a half a chance.

Speaker:

So one check, one fix this week.

Speaker:

And if you failed on the theming and connecting of the stuff together like

Speaker:

me, that one's usually bigger than your titles, and we'll look at that next week.

Speaker:

If you know a podcaster who should be doing this, send them

Speaker:

episode 100 and do it together.

Speaker:

Maybe pick a pub.

Speaker:

Compare your scores.

Speaker:

You can lie about yours.

Speaker:

I won't tell anyone.

Speaker:

Once again, the tool's at podmastery.co/health-check.

Speaker:

I'm Neal Veglio.

Speaker:

Thank you if you've listened to all 100 of these, and if you're

Speaker:

slightly newer, welcome along, and good luck with your continuing

Speaker:

journey towards attaining podmastery.

Transcript
Speaker:

This is episode 100 of Podmastery Podcasting Insights, and before we

Speaker:

start, I need you to do something.

Speaker:

Get your phone out, open your favorite podcast app, and find your own show.

Speaker:

Yours, not this one, yours.

Speaker:

If you're driving, then obviously don't.

Speaker:

Keep listening and come back to this bit when you're parked up.

Speaker:

I'd quite like you around with us to hit episode 101.

Speaker:

If you're not driving, go on, grab your phone, find your show.

Speaker:

I'll wait.

Speaker:

All right.

Speaker:

Got it?

Speaker:

Good.

Speaker:

Because this is episode 100, we're gonna do something a little bit different.

Speaker:

We're not gonna throw a self-congratulatory party where I'm

Speaker:

gonna replay clips of my favorite episodes or the most popular episodes

Speaker:

or any of that nonsense that shows celebrating milestones tend to do.

Speaker:

No, because this show is all about you.

Speaker:

It's not about me.

Speaker:

So we're gonna do something for you.

Speaker:

We're gonna audit your podcast together in real time right now

Speaker:

Hello, I'm Neal Veglio, the podmaster, and this is Podmastery Podcasting Insights.

Speaker:

I've been doing the podcasting thing for more than 25 years, in audio for 30.

Speaker:

and a quick confession from me before we get going with this.

Speaker:

A while back, on this very same podcast, I said that a podcast that genuinely fixed

Speaker:

your problems would probably be about 10 episodes long, and this is episode 100.

Speaker:

So make of that what you will.

Speaker:

Of course, there is nuance to everything, as I always say.

Speaker:

And when I said that, I was kind of thinking more in general terms of

Speaker:

going to the extreme of understanding when a show is self-interested.

Speaker:

In other words, when it's gatekeeping the real insight behind a paywall or behind

Speaker:

a book or behind its own vanity metrics of building followers and downloads and

Speaker:

all that stuff, then yeah, in theory, if a show is actually genuinely helping

Speaker:

you, it should probably have done its job within a handful of episodes.

Speaker:

But what that doesn't really fully explain is that when you've got something

Speaker:

as complicated as an industry such as podcasting, such as marketing in

Speaker:

general, you can't really get everything knocked off in 10 episodes, can you?

Speaker:

So like with everything, I said something in the most extreme version of what it

Speaker:

actually inhabits just to get you thinking

Speaker:

So here's what we're gonna get for episode 100 instead of a slice of cake.

Speaker:

Over the years, I've audited around 150 podcasts.

Speaker:

People usually pay me to do that for them, and the first thing I do every single

Speaker:

time is listen to the most recent episodes and check for a few of the same things.

Speaker:

Now, you're about to do these for yourself on your own show

Speaker:

while I talk you through it

Speaker:

Our first check is the editing.

Speaker:

So go to your latest episode, and in a moment when I tell you to, pause

Speaker:

this and press play and listen to the first minute, then come back.

Speaker:

All right?

Speaker:

So I'm not going anywhere.

Speaker:

Pause me now

Speaker:

Welcome back.

Speaker:

So two questions.

Speaker:

First of all, did you get into it quickly enough?

Speaker:

Did you get to the reason that your listener would have pressed play?

Speaker:

Was there a warm-up, a hello and welcome, a bit about the weather, a bit about

Speaker:

the weather where your guest is, a bit about where you're both apologizing for

Speaker:

the sound of the builders next door?

Speaker:

And then, and this is my favorite, the builders don't actually make a sound

Speaker:

for the whole episode, so the only thing anyone remembers is the apology

Speaker:

for the thing that never happened.

Speaker:

Secondly, how good was the edit getting them there?

Speaker:

Was it clean?

Speaker:

Or would I, as a listener, hear the joins?

Speaker:

Maybe a breath that stops halfway, an um that only half got cut, maybe another

Speaker:

um immediately after it which you missed

Speaker:

And here's a bigger question which you're gonna cringe over.

Speaker:

If you were tempted to skip forward in your own episode, even just a

Speaker:

little bit, so is everybody else.

Speaker:

They just didn't come back and tell you.

Speaker:

So make a note of that.

Speaker:

And we're gonna make check two now, which is your voice.

Speaker:

Okay, so we're gonna do it again, same thing, same minute And play

Speaker:

it again and then come back to me.

Speaker:

And this time, ignore what you're saying.

Speaker:

Just listen to how you're saying it, how it's recorded.

Speaker:

All right, you ready?

Speaker:

Get ready to pause me and press play.

Speaker:

Go

Speaker:

All right, hopefully you came back.

Speaker:

So does this sound close?

Speaker:

Does this sound clear?

Speaker:

Does this sound like we're sat next to you on the train?

Speaker:

Maybe in a theater waiting for a performance,

Speaker:

but with clear audio using something like maybe WhatsApp or FaceTime.

Speaker:

Or does it sound roomy and echoey, boxy, a bit of a ring to it like you

Speaker:

recorded it in a bathroom or a small carpeted cathedral full of coats?

Speaker:

Because that's the first thing that a new listener will be judging you on before

Speaker:

they've even heard a single idea from you.

Speaker:

You could have the best idea in your whole niche, but if it arrives sounding

Speaker:

like it was phoned in from inside a wardrobe, it doesn't get the chance

Speaker:

to be the best idea in your niche

Speaker:

All right, I think the pausing bit is done now because I'm

Speaker:

gonna hurt my own retention here.

Speaker:

So let's go with the things that don't require listening.

Speaker:

Let's go through the metadata.

Speaker:

So starting off, check three, titles.

Speaker:

Look at your most recent three episode titles.

Speaker:

Just read them to yourself

Speaker:

Would a stranger tap on any of them?

Speaker:

Somebody who's never heard of you.

Speaker:

On the bus, their thumb itching to click on something.

Speaker:

Is there a guest's name in there?

Speaker:

Because I'm gonna tell you, unless your guest is genuinely famous, and I

Speaker:

mean famous like a household name, like your mum's heard of them level famous.

Speaker:

Unless that's the case, nobody's tapping on a name.

Speaker:

A name doesn't tell me what I'm gonna be getting out of listening.

Speaker:

And now read all that together, all three, out loud if you're on your own.

Speaker:

Do they sound like they come from the same show?

Speaker:

I did this on mine before I sat down to record this very episode,

Speaker:

and here are my most recent three.

Speaker:

And let's be a little bit fair to this because the most recent before

Speaker:

this one was a bonus episode.

Speaker:

It was in the Opinions brand.

Speaker:

But the titles were Opinion: They're Telling Us There Are Too Many Ads,

Speaker:

How To Read A Podcast Script Without Sounding Like You're Reading,

Speaker:

and Here's What Definitely Won't Make Your Podcast Sound Better.

Speaker:

One's about ads, one's about reading a script, one's about what won't make you

Speaker:

sound better, and all three are true.

Speaker:

All three are useful, and read together, they sound like three different shows

Speaker:

that happen to share a microphone.

Speaker:

100 episodes in, my weak spot is the theming.

Speaker:

Yeah, I'm not gonna fix that in this episode, but I wanted you to hear

Speaker:

me say that out loud because if the bloke who audits podcasts for a living

Speaker:

can fail check three on his 100th episode, you're allowed to fail, too.

Speaker:

You're just not allowed to ignore that failure.

Speaker:

All right, now on to check four, which is descriptions.

Speaker:

Open your latest episode and read only the bit that you can see before it says more.

Speaker:

That's it.

Speaker:

That's all most people ever read.

Speaker:

Does that first line give a stranger a reason to click play on the player,

Speaker:

or does it say, "In this episode…"?

Speaker:

Because they know it's an episode.

Speaker:

They're inside a podcast app.

Speaker:

You've spent the most valuable line that you've got there

Speaker:

telling them where they are.

Speaker:

It's a bit like titling your podcast The X Podcast

Speaker:

It's the episodic equivalent of that.

Speaker:

It's a shop window with a sign in it that says shop

Speaker:

So let's get to the score then.

Speaker:

And this is by far not the end of this.

Speaker:

Don't worry, there is a very practical thing that we can get you to do if any

Speaker:

of this feels a little bit overwhelming.

Speaker:

But how many of those things did you pass?

Speaker:

If it's all four, brilliant.

Speaker:

Although I'd probably suggest getting someone else to check because nobody

Speaker:

marks their own homework harshly.

Speaker:

If you failed on the first one, the getting into it and the edit,

Speaker:

I'm gonna be straight with you.

Speaker:

Your listeners discovered that before you did.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And that's not a lovely thing to hear on a Monday, but every one of these

Speaker:

things is fixable this week, and not one of them is gonna cost you a penny

Speaker:

And now onto checks three and four, the titles and the descriptions.

Speaker:

And that's something that a tool can do, especially one I've built it.

Speaker:

So what I'd like you to do, because we're gonna keep coming back to this, I want

Speaker:

you to be able to practically sit down and continue auditing the basics of your show.

Speaker:

Go to podmastery.co/health-check

Speaker:

And then paste in your RSS feed.

Speaker:

Or if you don't have your RSS feed, just put your show name in there.

Speaker:

What this tool of mine does is it looks at your latest episodes, and it gives you a

Speaker:

score out of 10 in red, amber, and green.

Speaker:

It's completely free, and it uses the same red, amber, green technique that

Speaker:

I use in my audits that people pay for.

Speaker:

So it's the same standard.

Speaker:

It's just quicker, and honestly, a lot less emotional.

Speaker:

What it can't do is checks one and two, whether you get into it

Speaker:

quickly enough, how clean your edits are, how your voice is recorded.

Speaker:

A tool can tell you that your title's too long.

Speaker:

It just can't listen and tell you that you sound like you're

Speaker:

podcasting from inside a wardrobe.

Speaker:

That bit needs the ears, and that's the full audit.

Speaker:

That's me actually listening to your show, and you'll find the opportunity

Speaker:

to do that within your results.

Speaker:

Just stick your show name in there or your RSS feed and

Speaker:

click the Check My Show button.

Speaker:

You'll then get a follow-up email if you want it, and that will give you

Speaker:

the option to follow up with an audit.

Speaker:

So here's your one thing that you need to do for this week.

Speaker:

Pick the check that you failed worst at, just that one, and fix that

Speaker:

before your next episode goes out.

Speaker:

If it's your titles, write the next one out three times before you publish it.

Speaker:

Choose the one that resonates the most.

Speaker:

If you feel like it, stick it into your AI tool of choice and get it to give you

Speaker:

reasons why each is good or each is bad.

Speaker:

If it's your description, write a first line that would

Speaker:

make you want to press play.

Speaker:

Or if you wanna go really deep into this, ask somebody that isn't your

Speaker:

mum to give you their opinion on what would make them press play.

Speaker:

And if it's the edit or the voice, start with that first minute.

Speaker:

Get that minute right, and then the rest of your episode gets a half a chance.

Speaker:

So one check, one fix this week.

Speaker:

And if you failed on the theming and connecting of the stuff together like

Speaker:

me, that one's usually bigger than your titles, and we'll look at that next week.

Speaker:

If you know a podcaster who should be doing this, send them

Speaker:

episode 100 and do it together.

Speaker:

Maybe pick a pub.

Speaker:

Compare your scores.

Speaker:

You can lie about yours.

Speaker:

I won't tell anyone.

Speaker:

Once again, the tool's at podmastery.co/health-check.

Speaker:

I'm Neal Veglio.

Speaker:

Thank you if you've listened to all 100 of these, and if you're

Speaker:

slightly newer, welcome along, and good luck with your continuing

Speaker:

journey towards attaining podmastery.